Government

UK Announces Sweeping Immigration Reforms; Will Canada Follow?

The United Kingdom is making headlines after Prime Minister Keir Starmer unveiled a series of comprehensive immigration reforms on May 12, 2025. The measures, designed to tighten every aspect of the nation’s immigration system, aim to give the UK enhanced control over net migration and a more skilled workforce. The bold move has been met with applause domestically and is now prompting questions about whether Canada might follow suit.

A Transatlantic Dialogue

On the very same day as the UK announcement, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney engaged in a high-stakes conversation with Sir Keir Starmer. In their dialogue, Starmer congratulated Carney on his recent election victory, reinforcing the historic ties between the United Kingdom and Canada. With shared commitments to strengthening trade, commercial, and defence partnerships—as well as a common stance on upholding NATO values and supporting Ukraine’s peace efforts—the discussion hinted at potential policy alignments in the near future. The upcoming visit by His Majesty King Charles III to Canada later this month further underscores the deep and enduring bond between the two nations.

Potential Immigration Reforms on the Horizon for Canada

While Canada has long balanced economic needs, labour market pressures, and public sentiment in carving out its immigration policies, the latest UK measures have sparked debate on what changes might be on the table for the Canadian system. Experts suggest that Canada could consider adapting some of the following reforms:

      • Raising Skilled Worker Visa Thresholds: The UK plans to require degree-level qualifications for Skilled Worker visas, targeting a reduction in lower-skilled migration. In response, Canada could enhance its Express Entry system—potentially by increasing Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) score requirements or mandating higher educational credentials. This direction would align with Canada’s 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, which sees a reduction in permanent resident targets from 500,000 in 2024 to 395,000 in 2025, with a focus on attracting high-skilled talent for key sectors like technology and healthcare.
      • Sector-Specific Workforce Strategies: Just as the UK intends to require employers in industries such as engineering and IT to invest in domestic training, Canada might institute similar mandates for employers participating in its Temporary Foreign Worker Program. This would encourage the upskilling of Canadian workers and facilitate a smoother transition from temporary status to permanent residency.
      • Stricter International Student Regulations: With the UK reducing the post-study work period from two years to 18 months—and tightening compliance benchmarks for sponsoring institutions—Canada could consider modifications to its Post-Graduation Work Permit Program. Potential changes might include shortening work permit durations or enforcing more rigorous academic and completion standards for institutions, building on the country’s recent cap on international student permits for 2025.
      • Enhanced Language Requirements: The plan to raise English proficiency standards in the UK extends even to the dependents of skilled workers. Canada, which relies on tests like IELTS for its Express Entry and Provincial Nominee Programs, might look to elevate Canadian Language Benchmark (CLB) thresholds or introduce language proficiency tests for dependents, further bolstering integration for newcomers.
      • Efforts to Streamline Asylum Processing: With a backlog of over 260,000 refugee claims recorded as of late 2024, Canada faces pressure to reduce delays in asylum claim processing. Inspired by the UK’s approach to minimize human rights-based delays in deportation cases, there is speculation that Canada could adopt a “last-in, first-out” system or implement prioritization for high-acceptance-rate cases, aiming to uphold its international obligations while addressing domestic challenges.
      • Attracting Global High-Skilled Talent: The UK’s initiatives—such as the Talent Beyond Boundaries scheme and revamped Global Talent visa—target top-tier professionals. A similar expansion or the creation of a new Express Entry stream in Canada might be on the horizon, particularly for innovators in fields like artificial intelligence and green technology.
      • While Canada has long balanced economic needs, labour market pressures, and public sentiment in carving out its immigration policies, the latest UK measures have sparked debate on what changes might be on the table for the Canadian system. Experts suggest that Canada could consider adapting some of the following reforms:
      • Raising Skilled Worker Visa Thresholds: The UK plans to require degree-level qualifications for Skilled Worker visas, targeting a reduction in lower-skilled migration. In response, Canada could enhance its Express Entry system—potentially by increasing Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) score requirements or mandating higher educational credentials. This direction would align with Canada’s 2025–2027 Immigration Levels Plan, which sees a reduction in permanent resident targets from 500,000 in 2024 to 395,000 in 2025, with a focus on attracting high-skilled talent for key sectors like technology and healthcare.
      • Sector-Specific Workforce Strategies: Just as the UK intends to require employers in industries such as engineering and IT to invest in domestic training, Canada might institute similar mandates for employers participating in its Temporary Foreign Worker Program. This would encourage the upskilling of Canadian workers and facilitate a smoother transition from temporary status to permanent residency.
      • Stricter International Student Regulations: With the UK reducing the post-study work period from two years to 18 months—and tightening compliance benchmarks for sponsoring institutions—Canada could consider modifications to its Post-Graduation Work Permit Program. Potential changes might include shortening work permit durations or enforcing more rigorous academic and completion standards for institutions, building on the country’s recent cap on international student permits for 2025.
      • Enhanced Language Requirements: The plan to raise English proficiency standards in the UK extends even to the dependents of skilled workers. Canada, which relies on tests like IELTS for its Express Entry and Provincial Nominee Programs, might look to elevate Canadian Language Benchmark (CLB) thresholds or introduce language proficiency tests for dependents, further bolstering integration for newcomers.
      • Efforts to Streamline Asylum Processing: With a backlog of over 260,000 refugee claims recorded as of late 2024, Canada faces pressure to reduce delays in asylum claim processing. Inspired by the UK’s approach to minimize human rights-based delays in deportation cases, there is speculation that Canada could adopt a “last-in, first-out” system or implement prioritization for high-acceptance-rate cases, aiming to uphold its international obligations while addressing domestic challenges.
      • Attracting Global High-Skilled Talent: The UK’s initiatives—such as the Talent Beyond Boundaries scheme and revamped Global Talent visa—target top-tier professionals. A similar expansion or the creation of a new Express Entry stream in Canada might be on the horizon, particularly for innovators in fields like artificial intelligence and green technology.

Measures Likely to Remain Unchanged

Despite the possibility of adopting some UK-inspired reforms, several measures are unlikely to be mirrored in Canada due to differences in policy frameworks and social values:

      • Extended Settlement Periods: The UK’s proposal to double settlement periods from five to ten years and introduce an “earned settlement” model conflicts with Canada’s established pathway, which typically allows for citizenship consideration between three to five years after attaining permanent residency.
      • Social Care Visa Route Modifications: Unlike the UK’s social care visa, Canada’s Caregiver Program has proven essential in ensuring pathways for essential workers to secure permanent residency. Its modification or closure would run counter to the country’s commitment to critical service sectors.
      • Nationality-Based Visa Restrictions: The scrutiny of applications from specific nationalities—as seen in the UK's focus on nations like Pakistan and Nigeria—is at odds with Canada’s inclusive, non-discriminatory immigration principles.
      • Unique Refugee Work Permit Schemes: With an already robust framework for integrating UNHCR-recognized refugees, Canada is unlikely to create a separate work permit category akin to the UK's proposals.

Broader Context and Future Prospects

Canada’s immigration strategy is shaped by a mix of pressing economic needs, a low fertility rate of 1.3 births per woman, and an aging population—with immigrants constituting nearly 25% of the population. Public opinion, with roughly 60% of Canadians viewing current immigration levels as too high, adds further impetus for potential recalibration of policies. However, Canada’s foundational commitment to multiculturalism and humanitarian responsibilities—enshrined in the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act—ensures that any policy revamp will strive to balance economic pragmatism with the nation’s long-held values.

As discussions continue among policymakers, provinces, businesses, and civil society, the evolving Canada-UK relationship may catalyse a suite of collaborative immigration initiatives. With former Immigration Minister Marc Miller hinting at upcoming reforms aimed at streamlining asylum processing, the coming months promise to be a pivotal period for the future of Canadian immigration policy.

Looking Ahead

While the direct adoption of every UK reform appears unlikely, the transatlantic dialogue between Canada and the UK points to a future of greater policy convergence. As both nations navigate economic, demographic, and social challenges, the exchange of ideas may lead to innovative solutions that are tailor-made for each country’s context.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *